Among those who advocate hate-crime laws, it’s always the sexuality of the victim that’s front and center, not the sexuality of the criminal or the everyday, undifferentiated violence he took to extremity. Among the tolerance peddlers, it’s always the “lifestyle” of the gay guy, never the “lifestyle” of the straight guy or the culture of compulsory heterosexuality. Even among those who argue that the victim’s sexuality is irrelevant — that Shepard died just because a robbery went bad, or just because McKinney and Henderson were crazy on crank — the suggestion is that the crime is somehow less awful once homophobia is removed, and what is brewing inside the boys bears less attention. “The news has already taken this up and blew it totally out of proportion because it involved a homosexual,” McKinney’s father told the press.
Eighteen blows with a .357 magnum—murder happens.
— Excerpted from A Boy’s Life: For Matthew Shepard’s killers, what does it take to pass as a man? by JoAnn Wypijewski originally published in Harper’s magazine, September 1999. Quoted in ‘Ten Years Later,’ The Matthew Shepard Story Retold (NPR, October 12 2009)